session 2026-07-18: PENDING-62 lodged+ratified (REVIEWED-62 applied — 2b FIXes; wiring build cleared); S1 wrap

PENDING.md

@@ -1517,6 +1517,8 @@ Disposition (verbatim capture + executor action-list: `chamber-library/docs/libr
 
 > **⟳ RESHAPED + LIGHT-GATE PASSED 2026-07-16 — operative proposal text: `chamber-library/docs/PENDING-58-rewrite-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-16.md`** (gate ruling: `…-light-editor-gate-RULING-2026-07-16.md`). The body below is the 07-14 record; the gated proposal supersedes it on these points (Decision-2 rulings + light-gate, all landed): **`app[]` NOT produced** (2(i); was "produced-but-uncredited") · **`anchors[]` originates entirely in the citation amendment (#2)** — #1 produces none (2(ii) + §3(A), confirmed *entailed*) · `sections`/`provenance` = **produced-without-proof** (first-citation needs its own spot-check) · the three sub-questions **RESOLVED** (see Awaiting) · **REVIEWED-58 gates on residual-(b)** (first V-DSL exercise, Block 3), not a 128-book demonstration. Shed/inherit pair reconciled to identical (OQ-5).
 
+> **⟳ FORKS RULED + (f) AMENDED 2026-07-17/18 (REVIEWED-62):** the two 2b build forks RULED (`chamber-library/docs/2b-two-forks-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-17.md`) — credit the `app[]`-array kinds {`table`, `glyph`, `editorial-insertion`, `unrecognized`} + `list` *produced-with-a-content-edge*; "app[] not produced" = the **critical-apparatus channel** (variant-readings ledger; FIX-B naming), never the array. Item (f) amended on all three operative carriers per the Fork-2 ruling: *#1 produces no citation-credited `anchors[]`; the trusted per-scheme citation layer originates in #2; #1's wiring may retain the raw, uncredited `loeb-line` layer as #2's documented re-stamp input.* `sections` = produced-without-proof (alongside `provenance`), stated explicitly per the gate correction. **The wiring-build gate is CLEARED** (FIX-A ratified); residual-(b) still gates REVIEWED-58.
+
 **WHY THIS IS A REWRITE, NOT THE ORIGINAL:** The original PENDING-58 hung on a **reconciliation corollary** — `multiset(DSL-full) == multiset(candidate_body) ⊎ multiset(app[])` — which would have turned the corpus-health map's magnitude-diagnosis ("apparatus-shaped") into a **mechanical fact** (reconciles→apparatus / doesn't→body, no eyeballing). **That corollary is REFUTED and struck** — not renamed, not quietly dropped (steward + jurist explicit: a filing that drops its central justification and keeps the conclusion is what this process exists to prevent). The sidecar wiring never *depended* on the corollary; the corollary was a bonus hung on it. This rewrite argues the remaining, untouched case on its own merits.
 
 **THE REFUTATION, on the record** (evidence: 2026-07-13/14 session ledger; the demonstration `scratchpad/proto_reconcile.py` + `decompose_v2.py`; jurist rulings `docs/2b-sidecar-wiring-jurist-*-2026-07-13.md`):
@@ -1575,3 +1577,12 @@ Disposition (verbatim capture + executor action-list: `chamber-library/docs/libr
 **Recommendation:** FIX via editor-gate. **Semver/vehicle = steward call:** (a) fold into the **atomic** v2.1.0 supersession with #2/A3, or (b) a standalone v2.0.3 patch.
 **Files affected (on ratification):** §IV (licence axis) + §V (PREMIS naming note) by supersession; `graduation-spec.yaml` (the `licence` field + value vocabulary; any borrowed PREMIS terms, additive).
 **Awaiting:** ~~jurist editor-gate~~ **EDITOR-GATE PASSED 2026-07-17** (both FIX; 2 wording corrections applied + recorded in the draft Addendum: B(i) "may"→"must, where known"; B(ii) naming-only/no-pre-authorized-field). **STEWARD RATIFIED + REVIEWED-61 FILED 2026-07-17.** Semver/vehicle call (fold into atomic v2.1.0 vs standalone v2.0.3) resolved at landing. Paired draft: `chamber-library/docs/amendments-B-i-B-ii-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-17.md`.
+
+## PENDING-62 — FIX-A item-(f) seam clarification + FIX-B `app[]` naming collision (the two ruled 2b follow-ons, paired)
+**Date:** 2026-07-18
+**Tag:** [FIX] ×2 — jurist-classed (2026-07-17 Fork ruling), run **against a REVIEWED** because both touch ratified/just-landed content. **FIX-A GATES the 2b wiring build** ("the build proceeds on steps 1–3 once (f) is amended").
+**Summary:** The two FIX follow-ons the Fork ruling surfaced and required to run their own light FIX rather than ride the build silently. **FIX-A:** amend shed/inherit item (f) to the jurist's corrected sentence — *"#1 produces no citation-credited `anchors[]`; the trusted per-scheme citation layer originates in #2. #1's wiring may retain the raw, uncredited `loeb-line` layer as #2's documented re-stamp input"* — carried literally identical on all three operative carriers (PENDING-58 rewrite §1/§2 · citation JURIST-PACKAGE IV.7 · block-map reconciliation table), plus the Fork-1 credit enumeration landed in §1 (`list` labelled *produced-with-a-content-edge*). **FIX-B:** name the apparatus-ledger sense distinctly (**critical-apparatus channel**) in the sidecar-schema doctrine so `app[]` unambiguously means the schema array (3rd shared-name collision after manifest/PENDING-53, ABSTAIN/PENDING-55), + bring the doctrine's kind enumeration current with the three further fleet-v1 kinds ({`list`, `unrecognized`, `editorial-insertion`}, code-verified) via §4's own FIX lane.
+**Rationale:** The seam's conditions changed when #2 landed (v2.1.0, 2026-07-17); the OQ-5 discipline exists precisely so intent-vs-literal-wording gaps don't slip. The naming collision cost real orientation time in the Fork-1 ruling and will recur for the next reader. **Also surfaced:** a discovered internal tension in the operative PENDING-58 text (line 38 lists `sections` under *Trusted* while line 44 labels it *produced-without-proof*) — resolved in line 44's favour per the Fork-1 credit set, flagged for the gate to confirm, not silently fixed.
+**Recommendation:** One paired PENDING-62 (the PENDING-61 pattern), each FIX separately checkable; split to 62/63 only if steward prefers. **Verified: neither FIX touches the v2.1.0 spec** (zero occurrences of the seam/collision language — no re-supersession) nor any LOCKED field's meaning/shape.
+**Files affected (on ratification):** `docs/PENDING-58-rewrite-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-16.md` (§1 bullets, §2 table+keeps, §3 dated addendum) · `docs/citation-amendment-JURIST-PACKAGE-2026-07-17.md` (IV.7 row f + keeps; historical records untouched) · `_curation/constitution-close-block-map-2026-07-16.md` (row f + keeps) · `docs/sidecar-schema-DRAFT-v0-2026-07-12.md` (Naming note + line-68 comment + kind enumeration) · this file (⟳ annotation to PENDING-58's banner).
+**Awaiting:** ~~jurist light editor-gate~~ **EDITOR-GATE PASSED 2026-07-18** (`chamber-library/docs/2b-FIX-A-FIX-B-light-editor-gate-RULING-2026-07-18.md`, preserved verbatim — all 5 questions confirmed; the jurist named the 07-16 `sections` pass-through as their own miss; 1 correction applied + recorded in the brief Addendum: A2 states `sections`'s disposition explicitly, produced-without-proof alongside `provenance`). **STEWARD RATIFIED + REVIEWED-62 FILED 2026-07-18.** Edit-set APPLIED same day with bounded-diff proof (commit tagged REVIEWED-62): PENDING-58 rewrite A1–A8 · JURIST-PACKAGE IV.7 A9–A10 · block-map A11–A12 · sidecar-schema B1–B3 + §4 landing-table row · this file's ⟳ banner (A13). **FIX-A clears the 2b wiring build (steps 1–3); residual-(b) still gates REVIEWED-58.**