session 2026-07-24 (evening): PENDING-71/72 + REVIEWED-72/73 (both jurist-ruled) + evening session memory + KG drift-patterns + skill-harvest

REVIEWED.md

@@ -687,4 +687,16 @@ born-digital lane (whole-EPUB injection → per-spine) + promotion.scale_applica
 **Decision:** AUTHORIZED — promotion.scale_application ratified on the REVIEWED-70 Q2 substitute condition, grant scope legacy-witness-promotions ONLY.
 **Notes:** Jurist confirmation filed verbatim at chamber-library/docs/scale-application-levi-pilot-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-24.md; report + Addendum at
   docs/scale-application-levi-pilot-REPORT-2026-07-24.md. Condition met on all four legs. Carried with the grant (not conditions): (1) §6 substitution does NOT hold — source-fidelity remains undischarged; Flag-1 (pin V-TEXT reference params) is now LOAD-BEARING → no V-TEXT graduation runs before it closes; (2) corpus-scale arithmetic ~325-430 human-hours across 1,297 files is a steward pacing fact. converter-worse recorded UN-EXERCISED (not passed) alongside curation-to-carry; the 485 "mostly CONTENTS" characterization is inference pending census; fold extension to move into declared data. curation-to-carry's first demonstration bound to the first genuinely hand-curated work (open). Braşov adjudication + negative-control discipline affirmed.
-**If AUTHORIZED:** update graduation-spec.yaml promotion.scale_application status → ratified; Flag-1 gates the wave. Tag commits REVIEWED-71.
+**If AUTHORIZED:** update graduation-spec.yaml promotion.scale_application status → ratified; Flag-1 gates the wave. Tag commits REVIEWED-71.
+
+## REVIEWED-72 — PENDING-71 — Born-digital V-TEXT source-fidelity reference (design-gate passed; executor lean overruled)
+**Date:** 2026-07-24
+**Decision:** AUTHORIZED — proceed per the ruling. Ruling filed verbatim at chamber-library/docs/borndigital-source-fidelity-reference-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-24.md.
+**Notes:** Q1 confirmed and architectural (shared pandoc `-f epub` reader → reader-loss cancels a priori). Two problems separated: (i) shared-reader (structural, unfixable) and (ii) markup-noise (writer mismatch — Flag-1 fixed it); the package's "verifies markup not words" overstatement corrected to "blind to reader-loss only." Q2 ruled AGAINST the executor lean: NOT (b). The ruled reference design = the package's own run (3) — source-anchored + writer-matched (pandoc -t markdown-smart on the raw source EPUB), injection + glyph deltas declared-and-excused (PENDING-69 moved_to shape; fabrication elsewhere still flags), PLUS (a) a periodic per-format-class reader audit whose cadence/trigger (pandoc major-version bump, not calendar-only) + pass-criterion are declared data specified in advance (PENDING-67 Q3 discipline). Anchor upstream — run (3) checks injection+glyph+cleaners; (b) checked only cleaners. Q3 keep name "source-fidelity," claim scope bounded to the lane's reader. Q4 subsumed — pin the RULED design not the gfm-raw_html accident; Flag-1 recorded right-but-insufficient. Q5 47-file wave stays blocked; UNBLOCK = a clean-file PASS on the ruled design + a deliberate negative confirming a real prose loss still FLAGs. Clause 969/1046 reconciled (both survive): 969 = per-file check (run 3); 1046's cross-converter independence RELOCATED to the periodic audit, not struck — vacuity argument preserved. Amendment-process discipline gains: when a change reassigns a named component, check what else names it.
+**If AUTHORIZED:** Build the ruled reference design + specify the periodic audit as declared data + demonstrate the unblock condition (clean PASS + deliberate negative) on a real candidate → then the wave. Land the 969/1046 reconciliation as a §Tiering & Fence supersession (relocate 1046 to the audit). Tag commits REVIEWED-72.
+
+## REVIEWED-73 — PENDING-72 — Voice-purity sidecar as the engine-consumable graduation bar (design-gate passed, strengthened)
+**Date:** 2026-07-24
+**Decision:** AUTHORIZED — proceed per the ruling. Ruling filed verbatim at chamber-library/docs/engine-consumption-voice-purity-sidecar-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-24.md.
+**Notes:** Proposal confirmed + strengthened. FRAME ON ORTHOGONALITY: trim.keep answers "should this be preserved?"; voice-purity answers "whose words are these?" — orthogonal and anti-correlated where it matters (the Eichmann leak — Elon's Introduction + Bibliography — was trim.keep, correctly kept; extending the trim is the WRONG fix, it would delete content the corpus should hold). Q1 STRENGTHENED — sections[] must partition the file body EXHAUSTIVELY (every line to exactly one section; no gaps/overlaps), converting silence to assertion (the gate derives nothing here, so nothing else forces completeness). Q2 ruled CHAMBER-SIDE, produced + gated at graduation, engine reads it — because an engine-side sidecar breaks on every chamber re-conversion (ingest_gate sidecar-sha==live; PENDING-53 class, 5 standing FAILED rows since 2026-07-10). Q3 the gate checks existence + binding + schema + two mechanical falsifiers (exhaustive-partition; role from the closed vocabulary {text,paratext,apparatus,reference}), never boundary correctness. Q4 forbid the silent whole-file default forward; MIGRATE the 19 engine sidecars (not grandfather — Eichmann is among them, correct only after the leak), carrying _reviewed notes as attested_by AND adding REVIEWED-64 line_frame: landed-file declarations; backfill scope = engine corpus (~20), NOT chamber (1,297). Q5 V-SCAN baseline applies, rich does not (Warde: reproduced CUP Bible facsimile = apparatus). Cost: a per-file reading pass compounds on the boundary-drop pass — DESIGN the single-reading-pass (the two attestations from one read) before the wave.
+**If AUTHORIZED:** Land the amendment (constitutional requirement framed on orthogonality + declared-data mechanism: sections[] exhaustive-partition · closed-vocab role · chamber-side production · line_frame: landed-file · whole-file attestation) → build the widened sidecar_gate → migrate the ~20 engine sidecars → design the single-reading-pass. Tag commits REVIEWED-73.