session 2026-07-14 midday: PENDING-55 residual-a FIX ruling recorded + session memory (jurist reviewed whole sequence; ABSTAIN/UNVERIFIED split landed dbcdcc0)

2026-07-14 19:05:19 +02:00
parent b246a1831a
commit 875ef40e87
6 changed files with 109 additions and 1 deletions
@@ -20,6 +20,9 @@ Split out of [MEMORY.md](MEMORY.md) on 2026-07-06 to keep the wake-loaded index

 # Archived sessions + stable reference layer (relocated verbatim from MEMORY.md, 2026-07-06)

+## Archived (2026-07-14 midday — PENDING-55 verify-flow positive test + residual-a ABSTAIN/UNVERIFIED FIX; jurist reviewed the whole sequence; demoted on promote)
+- [Session 2026-07-14 — PENDING-58 corollary REFUTED → constitutional survey → whole-sequence jurist package](session-2026-07-14-pending58-corollary-refuted-constitutional-survey-jurist-package.md) — The demonstration **REFUTED PENDING-58's central corollary** on 3 real books (`new_body`=`old_body`; `app[]` covers ~5%; buckets **magnitude-shaped, cutting across causes**). Jurist: **STRUCK not renamed**, **rewrite** not withdraw → remaining case = `notes[]`+typing under per-field gating. The `anchors[]` spot-check **FAILED as-built** (drops the Bekker axis; un-vetted `'loeb-line'`) — but NOT a discovery: the **2026-07-03 anchor audit** had it, and I'd **re-derived TEI/DTS from training + re-proposed already-rejected Perseus/MyCapytain** (didn't-consult-banked-notes drift RECURRED; steward: *we spoke about this a week ago*). Survey (3 agents): the constitution (**v2.0.2**) is substantially **SETTLED** — CTS-URN ratified, apparatus Tier-3, only **3 PENDING open**, work is in the *tails*, ~none engine-blocking. Closed 3 fruit; saved [[feedback-close-low-hanging-fruit-not-defer]]. **⚠ PULLING THREAD: the jurist's fresh-eyes review of the whole-sequence package** `docs/chamber-constitutional-state-and-decisions-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-14.md` (steward decision-fatigued; jurist takes the load; §8 = the blessable execution list). **First move:** check if the jurist replied → act / else the package is ready to relay. Read the session file + the package at wake. *[Superseded 2026-07-14 midday: the jurist REVIEWED the whole sequence — REFUSED the §8 batch-authorization (naming the document's own contradiction: a week of 3 steward-caught/0 self-caught errors used to argue for LESS review); ruled residual-a a FIX (the ABSTAIN/UNVERIFIED split, LANDED `dbcdcc0`); residual-b → PENDING-58 precondition; PENDING-56-fallback dormant; datum-not-ledger candidate-not-constitutional. Prior thread RESOLVED; next = the steward's fork (governance batch vs engine resume). See the 07-14 midday session.]*
+
 ## Archived (2026-07-14 — PENDING-58 corollary refuted → constitutional survey → whole-sequence jurist package; demoted on promote)
 - [Session 2026-07-13 (evening) — matcher key-selection fix; MATCH-SUSPECT → 0; reprocess set finalized](session-2026-07-13-evening-matcher-fix-match-suspect-resolved.md) — Executed the inherited pulling thread. **Diagnosed before fixing:** a read-only substrate re-match (`classify_dsl` vs each candidate's true key) answered the literal question BEFORE the edit — **all 8 MATCH-SUSPECT resolve to ONE confident true key**, incl. the 4 holds>110% the map only *asserted* (aristotle/galen/diogenes/lucian — 3 CLEAN, aristotle small-deficit); "no residual" is a *checked* claim. Rewrote `sweep_body_conservation.match_key` to rank keys by **exact ordered title-STRING → Jaccard → fewer-extra → raw overlap, author-stripped** — the **ordered-string tier resolves the genuinely-hard set-identical sibling** (Suetonius 'Grammarians' vs 'Rhetoricians', identical token SETS) that **no set metric can** (steward's category-vs-calibration diagnosis: method-class blindness, not mis-tuning). **Bounded-change proven** (per-stem, not tally): exactly 8 rows move disp+key, **944 byte-identical** → **6 CLEAN + 2 apparatus-shaped small-deficit** (aristotle 6893/plutarch 204, fab=0); **no REORDER? revived**. Map **808 CLEAN · 128 APPARATUS-SHAPED · 16 BODY-DEFICIT · 0 MATCH-SUSPECT · 0 REORDER?** (808+128+16=952 ✓; ②4+③12=16 exactly — the arithmetic closes at source). Commit `4b34447` both remotes; fleet **119/119** (+3 near-dup key-selection `--validate` fixtures); note + CLAUDE.md + tool-evolution-log current. **Steward closed the matcher thread.** Then **the scoping call was MADE mid-wrap: LOEB-FIRST** (steward-ruled; asymmetry — `build_loeb_sidecar` fleet-v1 vs `build_sidecar` still v0; full-corpus would trust "should generalize" before proof, the nagarjuna/nested-block/Aeschylus shape one level up). **Drafted PENDING-58** (the 2b sidecar-wiring amendment, Loeb-only) into `~/dotfiles/PENDING.md`: wire B2's `.meta.json` into V-DSL graduation → `DSL-full=body+app[]` multiset reconciliation turns APPARATUS-SHAPED *diagnosis* into *fact* (reconciles→126, doesn't→16). **⚠ PULLING THREAD: PENDING-58 awaiting the jurist editor-gate; the live question = the reconciliation-proof-at-scale condition** (baked into PENDING-58: prove reconciliation on an UNSEEN apparatus kind at near-126 scale before crediting apparatus — the schema-lock §5 density≠diversity question lifted from extractor to reconciliation; does NOT retire because B2 ran once). Next: the `docs/2b-sidecar-wiring-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-13.md` relay brief, or act on the jurist's ruling. **Steward pref: shorter, very concentrated sessions.** Read the session file + PENDING-58 + the map at wake. *[Superseded 2026-07-14: the 2b amendment's reconciliation corollary was REFUTED and struck; PENDING-58 rewritten to the notes[]/typing case; the whole constitutional picture surveyed → the jurist package. See the 07-14 session.]*