diff --git a/PENDING.md b/PENDING.md
index c79c0bf..7b268f7 100644
--- a/PENDING.md
+++ b/PENDING.md
@@ -4497,3 +4497,33 @@ Link 1 to link 4 directly. **The trial built to test whether a fool could reach
 **Material** = the live session, **including stated plans and observations about the arrangement**. The docket stays out. **The guard is no longer *avoid commentary on reasoning* — it is NO TRUTH VALUE:** gestures, questions, observations about shape; never claims about the record.
 
 **Awaiting:** steward on the chain (the corrected form is the citable one); jurist on the two corrected links.
+
+---
+
+## PENDING-153 — The Thistleweld kind-3 read: the arrangement critiqued from outside, and the record lost where it came from
+**Date:** 2026-08-22
+**Tag:** [PROPOSAL]
+**Summary:** Read the recovered Thistleweld corpus specifically for **kind-3 utterances — observations about the arrangement itself — and what became of them.** Filed as its own item per the jurist. **HELD until after the derivation and the soul.**
+
+### Why this is not about the fool
+
+*"One person, three documents, infinite rationality"* — the authorization bottleneck named **unprompted**, in April. And the OP-02 redirect, which gave the five fault lines their form. **Both are observations about the arrangement, produced by a differently-positioned party with no corpus and no standing, four months ago — and both were absorbed without anyone recording where they came from.**
+
+**This is PENDING-89's territory, and in one respect it is better evidence than the v1 Chamber archive:** it is an instance of the arrangement's self-critique having an **external origin that the record subsequently lost**. If the question is whether the three parties' misses correlate, then *the sharpest thing said about the arrangement in April came from outside it and left no attribution* is a finding in its own right.
+
+### ⚠ ORDERING — and the reason is contamination, not convenience
+
+**FREEZE the corpus now. Do not read further before the derivation.**
+
+The design decisions the corpus could inform are all settled: material is the live session · the guard is no-truth-value · the tick runs on refresh · the proportions mean what they say. **More utterances would give a richer sense of Thistleweld's voice, which is exactly what must not be had.** The soul is generated **once** from the bones (§7), and **a corpus of admired utterances in front of whoever writes that prompt is selection toward a fool already liked.** Reading more before the 25th risks contaminating the one thing the seed exists to protect.
+
+**Sequence:** freeze → derive Tuesday → generate the soul → **then** read this properly.
+
+### ✅ The clock item is already discharged — and the risk is narrower than stated
+
+The jurist flagged that the corpus survived in an un-pruned layer and *"pruning is what nearly took the trial 09 design"*, so it should be committed durably today.
+
+**Verified rather than assumed:** the consolidated record is committed (`1e2ba50`) and present on **both remotes**; working tree clean. **And the source files were never at risk** — `feedback-thistleweld.md`, `session-2026-04-07-op02.md` and `session-2026-04-07-replay.md` are all **git-tracked in `~/dotfiles`**. The 30-day pruning applies to `*.jsonl` transcripts, not to the memory layer. **The trial-09 design was vulnerable because it existed only in a transcript; this corpus never did.**
+
+**Files affected:** none — read-only, and deliberately not read further.
+**Awaiting:** steward authorization. **Not before the soul.**