diff --git a/REVIEWED.md b/REVIEWED.md index c379700..54959d6 100644 --- a/REVIEWED.md +++ b/REVIEWED.md @@ -1894,7 +1894,7 @@ dispositions (REVIEWED-116 point 5). Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121-A1. 8. **Class A is a steward matter, and its consequence outlives the fix.** Three-valued reporting makes the two unclosable items honest; it does not make them closable. Renumbering their headers touches `PENDING.md` and is the steward's act, not the executor's. Recorded because it survives whatever is built: **`PENDING — ICP-19 Remit Expansion (Observer Problem)` will report open whether or not the steward–reviewer conversation it gates has taken place.** Its persistence in the open list is not evidence about the state of that conversation, and has not been since the item was written. The Observer Problem gate's status is steward testimony and reachable no other way. -9. …**The family is raised to a named ladder entry rather than a running count.** ⚠ AMENDED 2026-08-17, before execution, on the executor's surfacing of PENDING-141: the ladder's contents are a variable in a live pre-registered trial that cannot be e-run, and this condition would change the measured object. **The ladder entry is DEFERRED until that trial is graded at 84 transcripts, or until PENDING-141 is ruled otherwise.** The condition is not withdrawn — the family is real and the entry is owed. Two parts of condition 9 are severed: the lineage addition to this item's kin list touches PENDING-142 and not the ladder, and proceeds now; only the ladder entry waits. Recorded here rather than dropped, because a deferred entry with no record is how the family came to be rediscovered five times as a fresh coincidence. +9. …**The family is raised to a named ladder entry rather than a running count.** ⚠ AMENDED 2026-08-17, before execution, on the executor's surfacing of PENDING-141: the ladder's contents are a variable in a live pre-registered trial that cannot be re-run, and this condition would change the measured object. **The ladder entry is DEFERRED until that trial is graded at 84 transcripts, or until PENDING-141 is ruled otherwise.** The condition is not withdrawn — the family is real and the entry is owed. Two parts of condition 9 are severed: the lineage addition to this item's kin list touches PENDING-142 and not the ladder, and proceeds now; only the ladder entry waits. Recorded here rather than dropped, because a deferred entry with no record is how the family came to be rediscovered five times as a fresh coincidence. 10. **Scope of this ruling, stated rather than assumed.** I read PENDING-142 verbatim via `governance_item`, and independently observed `governance_state()` reporting PENDING-81 open against an AUTHORIZED REVIEWED-81 — one datum consistent with Class B, obtained from the instrument under review. Everything else — the census figures, the class memberships, the 39 stale `Awaiting:` lines, the docstring's wording — is executor testimony from a script I cannot run. That is precisely why condition 1 requires a hand-read key: the ruling cannot verify the census, and the acceptance check is the only instrument that can. @@ -1912,7 +1912,7 @@ dispositions (REVIEWED-116 point 5). Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121-A1. 2. CONDITION — **report N-now, and bound the hold.** 'Until graded at 84 transcripts' is not a date, and a hold with no expiry and no visible distance to expiry is how a temporary freeze becomes a permanent one. The executor reports the current transcript count at the next wake, and this item carries a **review point at 30 days** — not an automatic lift, a requirement to state where the count stands and whether the trial is still tracking. If N-now proves near 84, the steward may elect (b) on that fact; that election is not made here, because the fact is not in the record. -3. CONDITION — **entries earned during the freeze accumulate in this item as an owed-entries list.** A freeze without a queue is a silent loss, and the wrong-subject family now under REVIEWED- is already the standing example of what recurs unrecognised. They are queued **here** rather than in a new file: a separate holding document is one a reader might reach *instead of* the ladder, which is the same uncontrolled variable one layer along. Each queued entry names its authorizing ruling so the freeze lift is mechanical. +3. CONDITION — **entries earned during the freeze accumulate in this item as an owed-entries list.** A freeze without a queue is a silent loss, and the wrong-subject family now under REVIEWED-122 is already the standing example of what recurs unrecognised. They are queued **here** rather than in a new file: a separate holding document is one a reader might reach *instead of* the ladder, which is the same uncontrolled variable one layer along. Each queued entry names its authorizing ruling so the freeze lift is mechanical. 4. CONDITION — **grading does not authorize the append.** The item's second-order risk — that a tripled ladder may be a *worse* ladder, degrading per-entry reach even as the wake line raises the odds of opening the file — is real and is not resolved by grading the trial. On grading, the S2 batch **returns for a ruling**, not for execution, and that ruling addresses per-entry reach as its own question. Read as 'hold then append', (a) merely moves the problem four weeks and arrives with the same measurement still unmade. @@ -1924,4 +1924,4 @@ dispositions (REVIEWED-116 point 5). Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121-A1. 8. **Scope of this ruling.** I read PENDING-141 verbatim via `governance_item`. The trial's design, the 14%/77%/83%/0% retrieval figures, the 64-session base and the transcript count are executor testimony from instruments I cannot run. The ruling does not depend on their precise values — it depends on the asymmetry in Notes above, which holds across a wide range of them. Where it would depend on them is condition 2's election of (b), which is deferred until the count is in the record. -**If AUTHORIZED:** (a) is already the null action and remains in force; nothing needs doing to start it. Report N-now at the next wake. Open the owed-entries list on this item and queue the wrong-subject ladder entry deferred under REVIEWED-123 condition 9 as its first row. Set the 30-day review. Tag nothing — no commit follows from this ruling except the queue and the count. +**If AUTHORIZED:** (a) is already the null action and remains in force; nothing needs doing to start it. Report N-now at the next wake. Open the owed-entries list on this item and queue the wrong-subject ladder entry deferred under REVIEWED-122 condition 9 as its first row. Set the 30-day review. Tag nothing — no commit follows from this ruling except the queue and the count.