governance: REVIEWED-121 AMENDMENT 1 — formatting restored (steward)

⚠ AUTHORSHIP: steward's and jurist's, throughout. The executor commits, never
authors, ~/REVIEWED.md (Constitutional Constraint #1); content untouched here.

Restores the emphasis the earlier paste had stripped and removes the 2-space
body indent. Verified before staging rather than taken on report:
  · fences balanced (2), block holds exactly the three declared fields
  · 26 ** markers and 10 backticks present — the binding rule, A4 and the
    disposition read as prose again
  · 0 of 52 body lines indented; heading at column 0
  · register integrity sees 2 amendments; all 10 substantive elements present

Closes the sequence flagged at cd7e5b2 (truncated), completed at e7a3d68
(fence closed), and finished here. A3's binding rule is ratified and quoted
verbatim in corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml at cd6d4bf.
This commit is contained in:
David F Glidden
2026-08-17 14:23:26 +02:00
parent 3254dcb697
commit d31c9f3f6d
+51 -51
View File
@@ -1811,64 +1811,64 @@ fixture named as such.
**If AUTHORIZED:** the doctrine paragraph, point 7's defeater and point 9's disclosure are placed. `corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml` gains the two declared fields; no span is re-dispositioned by this entry — L926 (retracted, REVIEWED-118) and L1551 (reclassified, REVIEWED-119) are unchanged, and the immediate corpus effect is nil. The §5 F4 row is NOT amended, and point 3's cheap structural check is thereby lost: an F4 mark becomes compatible with both gold and negative, and a reader must consult the claim to know which. That is the price, stated here rather than left to be discovered. `ratio_A_to_B` stays **VOID** and is re-derived ONCE after **both** this entry and PENDING-137 land and all dispositions are recorded (REVIEWED-116 point 5). The fused-voice sub-type name (`negative_sub_type_OPEN`, REVIEWED-119 point 3) and the gold-schema question (REVIEWED-119 point 4) remain open and are decided by neither entry. `voice_stamp` remains unwired. No live instance exercises this doctrine at ratification; it is untested-in-force, and its first genuine exercise is the first newly-authored fr/en pair with reported speech. Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121. **If AUTHORIZED:** the doctrine paragraph, point 7's defeater and point 9's disclosure are placed. `corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml` gains the two declared fields; no span is re-dispositioned by this entry — L926 (retracted, REVIEWED-118) and L1551 (reclassified, REVIEWED-119) are unchanged, and the immediate corpus effect is nil. The §5 F4 row is NOT amended, and point 3's cheap structural check is thereby lost: an F4 mark becomes compatible with both gold and negative, and a reader must consult the claim to know which. That is the price, stated here rather than left to be discovered. `ratio_A_to_B` stays **VOID** and is re-derived ONCE after **both** this entry and PENDING-137 land and all dispositions are recorded (REVIEWED-116 point 5). The fused-voice sub-type name (`negative_sub_type_OPEN`, REVIEWED-119 point 3) and the gold-schema question (REVIEWED-119 point 4) remain open and are decided by neither entry. `voice_stamp` remains unwired. No live instance exercises this doctrine at ratification; it is untested-in-force, and its first genuine exercise is the first newly-authored fr/en pair with reported speech. Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121.
## REVIEWED-121 — AMENDMENT 1 (2026-08-14): the defeater is declared and permanently empty on the inherited set ## REVIEWED-121 — AMENDMENT 1 (2026-08-14): the defeater is declared and permanently empty on the inherited set
**Date:** 2026-08-14 **Date:** 2026-08-14
**Amends:** REVIEWED-121 (PENDING-134), points 7 and 8 and the closing paragraph. Recorded as an amendment sitting alongside the original, not an **Amends:** REVIEWED-121 (PENDING-134), points 7 and 8 and the closing paragraph. Recorded as an amendment sitting alongside the original, not an
edit to it: REVIEWED-121 is placed and executed, and no silent revision. edit to it: REVIEWED-121 is placed and executed, and no silent revision.
**Raised by:** the executor, during execution, unprompted by any ruling. The finding was not anticipated by PENDING-134, by the jurist package, or **Raised by:** the executor, during execution, unprompted by any ruling. The finding was not anticipated by PENDING-134, by the jurist package, or
by this seat. by this seat.
**Decision:** The executor's disposition is UPHELD. `defeater_has_ever_been_exercisable: false` stands as written and is the correct shape. One **Decision:** The executor's disposition is UPHELD. `defeater_has_ever_been_exercisable: false` stands as written and is the correct shape. One
further field is required (A3). The ratified doctrine is unchanged; no span is re-dispositioned; PENDING-134 is not re-opened. further field is required (A3). The ratified doctrine is unchanged; no span is re-dispositioned; PENDING-134 is not re-opened.
**What was found.** Point 7 replaced reader-independence with order-independence: a disposition recorded *before* the doctrine is consulted. For **What was found.** Point 7 replaced reader-independence with order-independence: a disposition recorded *before* the doctrine is consulted. For
all eleven inherited spans that moment is past and unrecoverable. Back-filling the field from a reading taken now would place a post-doctrine all eleven inherited spans that moment is past and unrecoverable. Back-filling the field from a reading taken now would place a post-doctrine
judgment in a field whose entire evidential value is that it precedes one — self-confirming, and the doctrine would have been ratified holding a judgment in a field whose entire evidential value is that it precedes one — self-confirming, and the doctrine would have been ratified holding a
defeater built from itself. The executor declined to populate and recorded the absence instead. That refusal is upheld: recording an honest empty defeater built from itself. The executor declined to populate and recorded the absence instead. That refusal is upheld: recording an honest empty
is the discipline, and the distinction it preserves — *never exercisable* is not *not yet defeated* — is the substance of the finding. is the discipline, and the distinction it preserves — *never exercisable* is not *not yet defeated* — is the substance of the finding.
**A1 — THE DEFECT IS IN POINT 7 AND IT IS THIS SEAT'S.** Point 7 asserts that order-independence is 'the stronger instrument in any case'. That **A1 — THE DEFECT IS IN POINT 7 AND IT IS THIS SEAT'S.** Point 7 asserts that order-independence is 'the stronger instrument in any case'. That
claim was unpriced in one respect. Personnel-independence is **retroactively** applicable: a second reader, had one existed, could have read spans claim was unpriced in one respect. Personnel-independence is **retroactively** applicable: a second reader, had one existed, could have read spans
already dispositioned. Order-independence is **prospective only**. The substitution was therefore not a strict gain — it traded an unavailable already dispositioned. Order-independence is **prospective only**. The substitution was therefore not a strict gain — it traded an unavailable
instrument for one that is unexercisable on everything that currently exists. Point 7's parenthetical stands as to contamination (two readers who instrument for one that is unexercisable on everything that currently exists. Point 7's parenthetical stands as to contamination (two readers who
both know the doctrine can both be led by it); it does not stand as an unqualified comparison, and is corrected here. both know the doctrine can both be led by it); it does not stand as an unqualified comparison, and is corrected here.
**A2 — 'UNTESTED-IN-FORCE' IS RESTATED AS UNTESTABLE, AND H1(b) IS SATISFIED PROSPECTIVELY ONLY.** REVIEWED-121's closing paragraph records the **A2 — 'UNTESTED-IN-FORCE' IS RESTATED AS UNTESTABLE, AND H1(b) IS SATISFIED PROSPECTIVELY ONLY.** REVIEWED-121's closing paragraph records the
doctrine as 'untested-in-force'. *Untested* implies testable-and-untested. On the inherited set the doctrine has **no defeater at all** — not a doctrine as 'untested-in-force'. *Untested* implies testable-and-untested. On the inherited set the doctrine has **no defeater at all** — not a
weak one, none — and cannot acquire one. The accurate statement: **the whose-proposition test is untestable on the entire inherited fr/en set, weak one, none — and cannot acquire one. The accurate statement: **the whose-proposition test is untestable on the entire inherited fr/en set,
permanently, and its defeater is exercisable only by newly-authored pairs.** H1(b)'s requirement that an AUTHORIZED doctrine state what would permanently, and its defeater is exercisable only by newly-authored pairs.** H1(b)'s requirement that an AUTHORIZED doctrine state what would
falsify it is met prospectively and not otherwise. This sharpens point 8 rather than replacing it: the single-reader condition is standing, and falsify it is met prospectively and not otherwise. This sharpens point 8 rather than replacing it: the single-reader condition is standing, and
this is its first priced consequence. this is its first priced consequence.
**A3 — ⚠ REQUIRED: THE LATCH WILL OTHERWISE DISCHARGE A DISCLOSURE IT DOES NOT COVER.** `defeater_has_ever_been_exercisable` is a monotone latch, **A3 — ⚠ REQUIRED: THE LATCH WILL OTHERWISE DISCHARGE A DISCLOSURE IT DOES NOT COVER.** `defeater_has_ever_been_exercisable` is a monotone latch,
which is right as far as it goes. But when the first newly-authored pair records a pre-doctrine disposition, the latch flips to `true` — and which is right as far as it goes. But when the first newly-authored pair records a pre-doctrine disposition, the latch flips to `true` — and
thereafter any recall figure pooled over the fr cell carries `true` while the inherited spans still carry no pre-doctrine disposition and never thereafter any recall figure pooled over the fr cell carries `true` while the inherited spans still carry no pre-doctrine disposition and never
can. One pair from outside the inherited set would silently discharge a disclosure covering eleven spans it has nothing to do with. That is the can. One pair from outside the inherited set would silently discharge a disclosure covering eleven spans it has nothing to do with. That is the
PENDING-136 denominator class — a fact true of one population read as true of another — and this instance would be **built into the mechanism** PENDING-136 denominator class — a fact true of one population read as true of another — and this instance would be **built into the mechanism**
rather than committed in prose. Fourth occurrence in this arc; the first that would be structural. Required alongside the latch, in rather than committed in prose. Fourth occurrence in this arc; the first that would be structural. Required alongside the latch, in
`corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml`: `corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml`:
```yaml ```yaml
defeater_has_ever_been_exercisable: false defeater_has_ever_been_exercisable: false
defeater_dispositions_recorded: 0 defeater_dispositions_recorded: 0
defeater_population: <cell + the criterion the count is taken over> defeater_population: <cell + the criterion the count is taken over>
``` ```
defeater_population is named, not assumed — this entry deliberately does not fix a number, because choosing the denominator from a point-in-time defeater_population is named, not assumed — this entry deliberately does not fix a number, because choosing the denominator from a point-in-time
read is the error the field exists to prevent. Binding rule: the latch may not be read without the count and the population in the same read. A read is the error the field exists to prevent. Binding rule: the latch may not be read without the count and the population in the same read. A
report may carry all three or none. report may carry all three or none.
A4 — ⚠ THE GROUND THE REFUSAL RESTED ON WAS CITED BY A NAME WITH NO REFERENT, AND THIS PARAGRAPH REPLACES THE DRAFT THAT MERELY CALLED IT A4 — ⚠ THE GROUND THE REFUSAL RESTED ON WAS CITED BY A NAME WITH NO REFERENT, AND THIS PARAGRAPH REPLACES THE DRAFT THAT MERELY CALLED IT
UNCITABLE. The refusal to back-fill was grounded in test_legacy_indices_are_not_self_verified, and the executor carried that name into UNCITABLE. The refusal to back-fill was grounded in test_legacy_indices_are_not_self_verified, and the executor carried that name into
corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml, commit 5425414's message and a steward report. No such function exists. This seat searched all 273 items in corpus/v2-stratum-tags.yaml, commit 5425414's message and a steward report. No such function exists. This seat searched all 273 items in
PENDING.md, PENDING-archive.md and REVIEWED.md for self-verified, found nothing, ran a positive control on defeater returning REVIEWED-121 and PENDING.md, PENDING-archive.md and REVIEWED.md for self-verified, found nothing, ran a positive control on defeater returning REVIEWED-121 and
PENDING-134 as expected, and concluded the test was reachable only from the executor's side. It was reachable from neither: the name occurs once in PENDING-134 as expected, and concluded the test was reachable only from the executor's side. It was reachable from neither: the name occurs once in
the entire repository, in a docstring at tests/test_reading_index.py:23 asserting that it 'holds that shut' — a label whose referent nobody had the entire repository, in a docstring at tests/test_reading_index.py:23 asserting that it 'holds that shut' — a label whose referent nobody had
opened. Fourth instance of cited-a-derived-label-instead-of-the-substrate, the class that let three documents protect a 0-byte fixture for seven opened. Fourth instance of cited-a-derived-label-instead-of-the-substrate, the class that let three documents protect a 0-byte fixture for seven
weeks. The reasoning is unaffected and the property IS tested, by checks citable by their own text: tests/test_reading_index.py L128 ('NO legacy weeks. The reasoning is unaffected and the property IS tested, by checks citable by their own text: tests/test_reading_index.py L128 ('NO legacy
region is "verified by fingerprint" — none stores one'), L130 ('a region with no stored fingerprint and no name test is UNVERIFIED'), and the region is "verified by fingerprint" — none stores one'), L130 ('a region with no stored fingerprint and no name test is UNVERIFIED'), and the
synthetic positive control at L281 ('a stored hash that DOES match yields verified by fingerprint') — without which L128's pass could be vacuous, synthetic positive control at L281 ('a stored hash that DOES match yields verified by fingerprint') — without which L128's pass could be vacuous,
which is precisely why a bare name was never sufficient ground. Corrected in the substrate at 966168b. which is precisely why a bare name was never sufficient ground. Corrected in the substrate at 966168b.
What does not change. The doctrine paragraph as ratified. Point 9's H3 disclosure. The conditionality on PENDING-131 (c) at point 5. No span is What does not change. The doctrine paragraph as ratified. Point 9's H3 disclosure. The conditionality on PENDING-131 (c) at point 5. No span is
re-dispositioned — L926 and L1551 stand as at REVIEWED-118 and REVIEWED-119. ratio_A_to_B remains VOID, still awaiting PENDING-137 and all re-dispositioned — L926 and L1551 stand as at REVIEWED-118 and REVIEWED-119. ratio_A_to_B remains VOID, still awaiting PENDING-137 and all
dispositions (REVIEWED-116 point 5). Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121-A1. dispositions (REVIEWED-116 point 5). Tag follow-on commits REVIEWED-121-A1.