session 2026-07-18: REVIEWED-58+63 placed — first 6 Loeb graduated (Block 1 closed; PENDING-63 full lifecycle in-day); S3 session file + ledger + harvest register + 3 KG lines

claude/memory/MEMORY-reference.md

@@ -5,7 +5,7 @@ metadata:
   node_type: memory
   type: reference
   originSessionId: d1e67361-d1b9-4dac-a0c4-e7a0e26211c4
-  modified: 2026-07-18T15:25:59.552Z
+  modified: 2026-07-18T17:02:43.740Z
 ---
 
 # MEMORY — Reference layer (consult on demand)
@@ -21,6 +21,9 @@ Split out of [MEMORY.md](MEMORY.md) on 2026-07-06 to keep the wake-loaded index
 
 # Archived sessions + stable reference layer (relocated verbatim from MEMORY.md, 2026-07-06)
 
+## Archived (2026-07-18 evening S3 — first Loeb graduations, PENDING-63 closed, Block 1 sealed; demoted on promote)
+- [Session 2026-07-18 (afternoon, S2) — 2b wiring BUILT test-first; fleet-proven, book untouched](session-2026-07-18-s2-2b-wiring-built-fleet-proven.md) — **Session 2 of the steward's 3-session plan: the build, sealed.** Composed in the ruled order — the per-field credit boundary as **DECLARED DATA** (`graduation-spec.yaml` `sidecar:` block, hook-passed on fresh grounding) → known-bad **fixtures** (novel kind/foreign scheme/coverage/pairing-dishonesty/missing-declaration all HELD; declaration-coherence pins YAML↔ruling so decl drift fails the fleet) → **`sidecar_gate()`** (V-DSL-only produce+validate beside `body_conservation_gate`; exact-`work:`-string bracketing; per-field disposition report states EVERY field both directions) + **the V-DSL body branch** (`_vdsl_verify` → `classify_dsl`; **closes the false-ABSTAIN** a `.dsl` source took via V-UNKNOWN — the resolution the substrate had pre-assigned to this caller). **Fleet 141/141 · real dry-run inert · purely-additive diff (512+/0−) · `7f98488`+`c9b09f8` both remotes · NO book touched.** **S1's literal Q ANSWERED: the credit boundary translated cleanly — what acting surfaced sits one layer beneath:** (1) the **line-ref coordinate contract is unruled** (producer body-array indices vs schema file-coordinate examples + frontmatter offset) — HELD OPEN, no consumer binds lines, travels WITH residual-(b) to REVIEWED-58, deliberately NOT a new PENDING; (2) flagged executor judgment: `write_sidecar` **re-stamps** source_file/sha/lines to the LANDED artifact (grounded in `engine_source_binding`; binds the file, not line geometry). Self-caught honesty item: "test-first" was fixtures-first — red never observed; teeth evidence = the known-bad fixtures. *[Superseded 2026-07-18 evening: **Session 3 + the day's full arc executed** — the exercise PASSED (6/6, fab 0 · lost 0), REVIEWED-58 placed (Block 1 closed), PENDING-63 ruled+built+landed same day, the first 6 Loeb graduated through the observed apply (REVIEWED-63). All three S2 flow questions met: (a) became PENDING-63's compound-source form; (b) was flow (frontmatter+title-block prep); (c) observed on Ion, unbound. See the S3 session file.]*
+
 ## Archived (2026-07-18 afternoon S2 — 2b wiring BUILT test-first, fleet-proven; demoted on promote)
 - [Session 2026-07-18 (morning, S1) — REVIEWED-62 applied; 2b wiring build CLEARED](session-2026-07-18-s1-reviewed-62-applied-wiring-gate-cleared.md) — **Session 1 of the steward's 3-session plan, complete end-to-end in one morning.** Drafted the paired FIX brief from the substrate ((f) censused to exactly **3 operative carriers**; **spec verified clean** → no re-supersession; **five `app[]` kinds code-verified** at `build_loeb_sidecar.py:148–231` vs the 2-kind doctrine — the assert-X-in-Y antidote's first post-lesson use, HELD), **surfaced a real internal tension** (PENDING-58 line-38 `sections` *Trusted* vs line-44 *produced-without-proof*) as a gate question, not a silent fix → **jurist PASSED all 5 questions, 1 correction** (state `sections`'s disposition explicitly — applied), **named the 07-16 miss as their own**, and minted the method lesson: *"a gate that passes a document and a build that has to implement it are different tests"* → **REVIEWED-62 filed mid-turn** (substrate-verified at `~/REVIEWED.md:580` before acting) → **edit-set APPLIED with bounded-diff proof** (16 hunks each mapped; canonical (f) **byte-identical ×4 placements**; `e36f561`→`6d6268a`, both remotes; ruling preserved verbatim). Two flagged executor judgments (GROUNDED-IN attestation on pre-hook Doc 1 — the hook checks content presence; §4 landing-table row for B3's kinds). Residual noted-not-acted: Doc-1 line-45 parenthetical still uses the old token (Naming note disambiguates). **⚠ PULLING THREAD: Session 2 — build the wiring test-first** (`sidecar_gate()` beside `body_conservation_gate` + `graduation-spec.yaml` declaration + `test_tools` fixtures per the ruled credit boundary: notes[]+{table,glyph,editorial-insertion,unrecognized} trusted · `list` content-edge · sections/provenance/`loeb-line` produced-without-proof · critical-apparatus channel not produced; **build+fleet-test, don't run on a book**) → Session 3 first exercise → residual-(b) → REVIEWED-58. **LITERAL Q (S2): does the ruled per-field credit boundary translate cleanly into gate code + fixtures — or does *implementing* it surface a per-kind decision the paper rulings didn't anticipate?** (S3's exercise question stays held behind it.) Read the session file at wake. *[Superseded 2026-07-18 afternoon: **Session 2 executed** — the wiring BUILT test-first (declared boundary in `graduation-spec.yaml` `sidecar:` + `sidecar_gate()` + the V-DSL body branch; fleet 141/141; dry-run inert; `7f98488`/`c9b09f8` both remotes). The literal question ANSWERED: the credit boundary translated cleanly; acting surfaced the layer beneath — the line-ref coordinate contract (HELD OPEN → residual-(b)) + the re-stamp binding judgment (flagged). See the 07-18 S2 session.]*