diff --git a/REVIEWED.md b/REVIEWED.md index 53077f3..7cf3d64 100644 --- a/REVIEWED.md +++ b/REVIEWED.md @@ -1964,3 +1964,66 @@ it should not be applied to this corpus. **If AUTHORIZED:** Record trial 09 void. Pre-register the replacement run's instrument in full before any token is generated. Tag commits REVIEWED-124. THE HOLD ON TRIAL 09 IS PERMANENT — it does not lift; it is superseded. + +## REVIEWED-125 — PENDING-149 — Buddy-pattern Fool: §8a answered, §8 measured, §5 contested + +**Date:** 2026-08-22 +**Ruling:** PARTIAL — see per-deliverable dispositions below. +**Does not bear on PENDING-150.** No fourth position is ratified by this ruling; +`~/CLAUDE.md` is untouched. §13.6 continues to block every run. + +### §8 measurement — AUTHORIZED as evidence +4.2 events/day over 45 days, 6.2 on active days, range 1–53, sessions 1.39/day. +This is what §8's closing warning asked for and the burst finding is sound: fixed +proportions on a bursty event generator make the fool loudest on the heaviest days. +The defect is real and is a defect in the draft, not in the executor's reading. + +### §8 recommendation (keep 73/20/7 + hard daily cap) — REJECTED +Two grounds. +(a) §8's tuning prohibition is a bar on *runtime* adjustment — its stated rationale +is a fool that learns from being heard or muted. It does not bar a one-time +pre-registered proportion, which §8 explicitly requests. +(b) A hard cap is the more §8-hostile mechanism: it creates an observable +'quota exhausted' state, arriving first on burst days, after which silence reads as +depletion rather than as the 73%. That defeats §8a's object. +Rejection is of the mechanism, not of the problem it addresses. + +### §8 re-derivation — DEFERRED, conditions stated +Executor to return with adjusted proportions, pre-registered and hardcoded, no cap. +If the executor's answer requires the trigger key to change, that is an amendment to +§8 and is filed as such — not carried inside an §8a answer. + +### §8a body/voice split — AUTHORIZED, conditional +The separation of body from voice is adopted; it is the answer §8a wanted, and it is +a fourth shape rather than a selection from the three, which §8a invited. +Conditions, both prior to build: +1. Verify whether `statusLine` is already configured in `~/.claude/settings.json`, + and what it carries. Flagged unchecked at filing; the option's cost and its one + risk both turn on it. +2. The body must RENDER silence, not merely occupy a line. A static name is a label + and goes furniture-blind; §3 bars sprites and animation frames, so whatever + changes must be derived from time or from nothing. Never from content — content + derivation makes the body gradeable and §2 forbids it. + +### §5 — five axes stand; PROCEDURE not adopted +Not adopted on §5's own criterion: an axis is real only if a dump on it is imaginable +as costing the steward something. If procedural failures are already caught by +existing instruments, blindness there is free. The executor's second reading is +correct. §5 remains awaiting steward ratification, which is upstream of the bones and +is not a jurist matter. + +### `input-dependence-01-PREREGISTRATION.md` — DEFERRED, explicitly not parked +Held at the gate. Reconsidered when §12's swappable-generator clause becomes live +work; it is the nearest existing instrument for reading divergence between two +formations. Disposal by omission is refused. + +### PENDING-89 evidence, source (iv) — AUTHORIZED to read +`~/_Dev/animal-davidglidden-eu/chamber-sessions-private/` (55 files). Flagged +2026-08-01, never opened. It answers generation diversity, not correlation of misses, +and must not be reported as the latter. The executor's statement that the buddy fool +contributes zero to PENDING-89 by construction is accepted as a design property. + +### Scope note +The jurist could not read the filed draft via `governance_read`; the text ruled on was +supplied by the steward in-session. The filed sha256 `9aceed7f…` is unverified from +this side. \ No newline at end of file