David/dotfiles
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

session 2026-07-17: constitution block drafted-whole — #2/#4/#5 RATIFIED (REVIEWED-60/61, PENDING-60/61), verify-before-compose hook + memory, MEMORY.md compacted

Browse Source
This commit is contained in:
David F Glidden
2026-07-17 16:11:58 +02:00
parent 4bf7f1ad67
commit ed43422bbb
9 changed files with 171 additions and 20 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
PENDING.md
+19
View File
@@ -1556,3 +1556,22 @@ Disposition (verbatim capture + executor action-list: `chamber-library/docs/libr
**Full proposal:** `chamber-library/docs/A3-self-audit-PROPOSAL-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-16.md`. **Jurist review PASSED 2026-07-16** (`…-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-16.md`), 3 edits applied + a mechanism gap closed.
**Files affected (on ratification):** a new spec section (*Trust Attestation / Self-Audit*, cross-ref §IX); a census tool for the two flag dimensions; the cold-instance legibility-audit procedure.
**Awaiting:** ~~steward ratification~~ **RATIFIED 2026-07-16 (REVIEWED-59).** Land as a new spec section by supersession + semver on the steward's version call (v2.0.2 → v2.1.0 suggested). Jurist review passed.
## PENDING-60 — Citation amendment (#2): specify the adopted CTS-URN model + draw the chamber-minted-namespace / internal–external boundary + per-scheme coverage attestation
**Date:** 2026-07-17
**Tag:** [PROPOSAL] — normative spec amendment (new doctrine + changes what graduation produces re: citation). Runs the §Governance & Amendment editor-gate (executor drafts → jurist editor-gates format + doctrinal soundness → steward ratifies); lane = freeze + semver.
**Summary:** The citation amendment — #2 (the heaviest) of the constitution-close block. The **CTS-boundary precondition is MET** (`chamber-library/docs/CTS-boundary-for-citation-amendment-2026-07-17.md`); its clean-separation verdict is **CONFIRMED** by the parallel tier survey (`chamber-library/docs/FABLE-tei-cts-dts-perseus-tier-survey-2026-07-17.md`) — the seam is the CTS standard's **own published** notation-vs-protocol split. **Reconciliation (verify-before-compose):** §III (citation contract), §IV (CTS-URN edition-identity — *the adopted scheme*), §VII (declared locator registry), and §IX (coverage-ledger + evidence-tier) are **already ratified**; #2 does NOT re-adopt them. #2 **specifies**, building on them: (1) the **chamber-minted CTS namespace** + the **internal (T1) / external (T2, leashed Condition-2) boundary** — the genuine new decision §IV left open; (2) **per-scheme in-source anchor recovery** (routing → `graduation-spec.yaml` declared data, per §VII's generative principle); (3) the **per-scheme coverage attestation** (§IX-as-precondition; honest-degradation, attest-never-default, work-level default per §III's sectionless reduction; relates to §IX's OPEN silence-as-finding); (4) **Decision-1** + additive-only sidecar fields.
**Rationale:** The classical (V-DSL, 952) tier is staged-flattened, **0 graduated**; a trustworthy citable v1 needs the citation model specified so anchors are recovered *where verified* and honestly attested *where not*. #2 is the constitution's last heavy piece before corpus-into-spec (pull-based) opens. Body extracts cleanly; the per-scheme anchor recuperation is the hard part — absorbed by the coverage attestation (threshold = a production measurement, not a doctrinal commitment).
**Precondition:** MET — CTS boundary drawn + B-confirmed; no T2 question requires resolution before drafting.
**Recommendation:** PROPOSAL via editor-gate. **Semver = steward call** on the §Governance test ("does it change what a gate accepts?"); rec **MINOR v2.1.0** (additive fields + new doctrine, forward-only — 0 Loeb verified), **coordinate with A3's (PENDING-59) v2.1.0 landing**.
**Files affected (on ratification):** §III/§IV/§VII/§IX (by supersession + semver); `graduation-spec.yaml` (per-scheme parser routing + locator-registry additions + coverage-attestation fields); the structural sidecar schema (additive fields, REVIEWED-56 discipline); the ~3,333-anchor `loeb-line`→per-scheme re-stamp (production/Region-4).
**Awaiting:** ~~jurist editor-gate~~ **EDITOR-GATE PASSED 2026-07-17** (`docs/citation-amendment-JURIST-editor-gate-ruling-2026-07-17` — jurist ruling; Q1 namespace-minting-in-`urn:cts:` confirmed, Q3/Q4 confirmed). **Two corrections + one condition DISCHARGED** (recorded in the package Addendum): (Q2) IV.3 reworded as an *explicitly partial* answer to §IX (general silence-as-finding stays OPEN); (Q6) #1's live shed-list cross-checked side-by-side vs #2's IV.7 — **six-for-six identical, (f) "originates" in both** (seam closed); (Q5) additive-only **verified against the LOCKED schema** (`anchors[].scheme` already present; `citation_coverage[]` = new optional field = FIX) → **MINOR (v2.1.0) stands**. **STEWARD RATIFIED + REVIEWED-60 FILED 2026-07-17.** MINOR v2.1.0; semver/vehicle (atomic-v2.1.0-with-A3[/#4/#5] vs sequenced) = steward annotation on placement. Production deps run post-ratification. Self-contained package: `chamber-library/docs/citation-amendment-JURIST-PACKAGE-2026-07-17.md`.
## PENDING-61 — B(i) `licence` axis + B(ii) PREMIS borrow-vocabulary (the two light constitution-close FIXes, paired)
**Date:** 2026-07-17
**Tag:** [FIX] — two ordinary spec amendments (gap-fill; **no gate-acceptance change**). §Governance & Amendment editor-gate (executor drafts → jurist editor-gates format + doctrinal soundness → steward ratifies); lane freeze+semver.
**Summary:** Block-1 #4 + #5 — the last light items. **#4 (B(i)):** add a `licence`/copyright-status **provenance axis** to §IV — machine-readable rights status of the *edition converted* (`public-domain` | open-licence | `in-copyright` | `permission-granted` | `unknown`), **graceful-degradation** (backfilled-not-rejected), **never a gate**; value vocabulary = declared data in `graduation-spec.yaml`. **#5 (B(ii)):** name the existing §V preservation-metadata layer (the W3C-PROV-shaped conversion record + fixity) using **PREMIS as borrow-vocabulary** (the DTS "borrow-vocabulary, build thin" posture, 07-04) — a **legibility** move, **no external dependency/schema/service**, terms as declared data; §V's shape/requirement **unchanged**. Both grounded in §IV/§V (quoted in the draft). B(iii) already landed (v2.0.2, REVIEWED-51) — not reopened.
**Rationale:** REVIEWED-49 "B — ordinary amendments confirmed… normal FIX per item." Closes the block's light tail; the corpus's heterogeneous rights need a machine-readable axis, and the preservation layer needs a legible standard name.
**Recommendation:** FIX via editor-gate. **Semver/vehicle = steward call:** (a) fold into the **atomic** v2.1.0 supersession with #2/A3, or (b) a standalone v2.0.3 patch.
**Files affected (on ratification):** §IV (licence axis) + §V (PREMIS naming note) by supersession; `graduation-spec.yaml` (the `licence` field + value vocabulary; any borrowed PREMIS terms, additive).
**Awaiting:** ~~jurist editor-gate~~ **EDITOR-GATE PASSED 2026-07-17** (both FIX; 2 wording corrections applied + recorded in the draft Addendum: B(i) "may"→"must, where known"; B(ii) naming-only/no-pre-authorized-field). **STEWARD RATIFIED + REVIEWED-61 FILED 2026-07-17.** Semver/vehicle call (fold into atomic v2.1.0 vs standalone v2.0.3) resolved at landing. Paired draft: `chamber-library/docs/amendments-B-i-B-ii-FOR-JURIST-2026-07-17.md`.