diff --git a/PENDING.md b/PENDING.md index a5999f6..f954a47 100644 --- a/PENDING.md +++ b/PENDING.md @@ -5360,6 +5360,8 @@ A marker with an implementation is a channel; a channel is option 3 by the back ### AMENDMENT 2 — 2026-08-25 — the fourth position contributes NOTHING to this item, now by ruling; and where the evidence actually is +**Ruled: REVIEWED-129** (PENDING-159, option 1). This amendment is that ruling's consequence 1, filed here because this item is the consumer. + **Steward decision on PENDING-159: option 1. Nothing marked, nothing built, no flag that could become a channel.** ⚠ **This item's zero-contribution statement was already owed and is now LOAD-BEARING.** It was previously true *by construction* — the fool produces nothing filable. It is now also true *by ruling*: no provenance marker exists or will, so **no observation of Tarbuckle's will ever reach this item in any form, marked or unmarked.** @@ -5406,7 +5408,7 @@ Named here so that a later reader looking for the correlation datum does not go deletion, one occasion. --> -### AMENDMENT 3 — 2026-08-25 — ⚖ STEWARD DECISION: option 1. The item closes. +### AMENDMENT 3 — 2026-08-25 — ⚖ STEWARD DECISION: option 1. The item closes. **Ruled: REVIEWED-129.** **Option 1. Accept the loss. Nothing marked, nothing built, no flag that could become a channel.** diff --git a/claude/governance/REVIEWED-128-129-draft-for-placement.md b/claude/governance/REVIEWED-128-129-draft-for-placement.md index 48210d6..e864135 100644 --- a/claude/governance/REVIEWED-128-129-draft-for-placement.md +++ b/claude/governance/REVIEWED-128-129-draft-for-placement.md @@ -1,3 +1,26 @@ +# ⚠ SUPERSEDED — PLACED 2026-08-25. DO NOT EDIT THIS FILE. + +**Both rulings are canonical in `~/dotfiles/REVIEWED.md`** — REVIEWED-128 at line 2262, +REVIEWED-129 at line 2318. This file is retained as the drafting record only. + +**Superseded in place rather than deleted**, on the same ground as the REVIEWED-127 +draft: an unmarked parallel version of a canonical record is the context-rot failure +`CLAUDE.md` names outright. Deleting it would lose the drafting history; leaving it +unmarked would leave two live versions and no way to tell which governs. + +**Placement verified rather than assumed**, 2026-08-25: both blocks are +whitespace-normalised identical to what was placed — 4,230 and 5,378 characters on both +sides. The placed text differs only in line wrapping, which the steward's editor +re-flowed. ⚠ **Checked because "drafted, then placed" is exactly where a ruling's subject +and its artifact drift apart**, and this record already carries that class recurring +inside a ruling (PENDING-82/86). + +⚠ **REVIEWED-129's `Decision:` line was blank in this draft and is filled in the placed +record.** The steward decided option 1; the executor did not supply it. If this file is +ever read for the decision, it does not have it — read `REVIEWED.md`. + +--- + # Drafts for steward placement — REVIEWED-128 and REVIEWED-129 Drafted by the executor 2026-08-25 from the jurist's rulings relayed by the steward. diff --git a/claude/governance/fool/TARBUCKLE-SPEC-13.1-2026-08-25.md b/claude/governance/fool/TARBUCKLE-SPEC-13.1-2026-08-25.md index aa4d933..a7e6e41 100644 --- a/claude/governance/fool/TARBUCKLE-SPEC-13.1-2026-08-25.md +++ b/claude/governance/fool/TARBUCKLE-SPEC-13.1-2026-08-25.md @@ -161,7 +161,7 @@ its constraint budget there, and a violation is still silence. | `tarbuckle-draws.jsonl` | occurrence only — surface + outcome | **permanent.** Counting is not filing; §8 obliges a rate and a rate needs a denominator | | `tarbuckle-rejects.jsonl` | violation reason **+ up to 200 chars of a suppressed line** | ⚠ **temporary, dies 2026-09-08** | -**Jurist ruling, 2026-08-25.** The rejection log is *"a log of my instruction, not of +**Jurist ruling, 2026-08-25 — placed as REVIEWED-128.** The rejection log is *"a log of my instruction, not of Tarbuckle… the rejected lines were never uttered: he was silent, and the log holds what silence cost."* Nothing in it entered the room, so nothing can be cited from it. **Three binding conditions:** @@ -208,9 +208,11 @@ prevent exactly that.** Recorded rather than silently corrected. - ~~**The wrap seam**~~ — **BUILT** 2026-08-25 on `Stop` + `systemMessage`, gated on an actual `/wrap-up` invocation detected structurally in the transcript. `SessionEnd` remains unusable and the reason stands in §4. -- **PENDING-159** — the fool cannot reach the jurist, and what does reach him arrives - without provenance. `[ESCALATE]`, jurist view received: option 2 narrowly, optional, - **and deliberately unimplemented** — a marker with an implementation is a channel. +- ~~**PENDING-159**~~ — **CLOSED, REVIEWED-129:** option 1. The fool cannot reach the + jurist and **nothing is marked, nothing built, no flag that could become a channel.** + Declined as harmful rather than expensive: a marker would have weighted the steward's + judgement in the one place it must stay unweighted. ⚠ **REJECTED, not deferred — not to + be revisited without new steward input.** - **The two-week rate report** — §8 obliges it; `DEFERRED-DECISION: mumble-rate-two-week-report`, converted `manual` → `date 2026-09-08` the day the body shipped. - **Frequency remains UNKNOWN** and is not guessed. The invocation log now measures the