David/dotfiles
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases Wiki Activity

governance: close PENDING-75 — REVIEWED-75 placed, v2.7.0 landed

Browse Source 
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01Xefg5EXwcpd9RMAr63dWrD
This commit is contained in:
David F Glidden
2026-07-27 19:35:59 +02:00
co-authored by Claude Opus 4.8
parent d7824cffe8
commit ffb9b09b48
1 changed files with 1 additions and 1 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
PENDING.md
+1 -1
View File
@@ -1725,4 +1725,4 @@ Disposition (verbatim capture + executor action-list: `chamber-library/docs/libr
**Files affected (on ratification only, drafted to the Addendum's corrected design):** `docs/chamber-library-specification.md` (§Tiering & Fence + §V), `docs/sidecar-schema-LOCKED-2026-07-12.md` (naming note). Nothing built/run/landed now. **Files affected (on ratification only, drafted to the Addendum's corrected design):** `docs/chamber-library-specification.md` (§Tiering & Fence + §V), `docs/sidecar-schema-LOCKED-2026-07-12.md` (naming note). Nothing built/run/landed now.
**RULED 2026-07-25 — design-gate PASSED, with one REQUIRED correction** (`docs/kind-scoping-verification-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-25.md`). The jurist **adopted the package's Part-4 argument over his own framing**: the foreclosure is not that a non-text work *fails* the criterion but that the criterion is **VACUOUS** on it (empty re-extraction is trivially prose-word-identical to itself) — the false-positive shape, caught prospectively for the first time rather than after a finding. **Required correction:** Edit 1's *"that method is prose-word identity … (V-DSL · V-TEXT · V-SCAN)"* **overstates against V-SCAN**, whose ratified row says *no ground-truth text* and whose bar is *"a distinct, named, more-expensive criterion — not the deterministic bar relaxed"* — the scoping sentence must not flatten a distinction the table already draws. **Q1** placement at the evidence-tiers preamble CONFIRMED (that is where method is *defined*; tier-1 would scope the bar and leave the definition unscoped). **Q2** guard kept and **rebound to the property, not enrollment** (*"a text-bearing work … no work may weaken its applicable method"*) — as drafted it reached only existing kinds and would open the moment the door is first used. **Q3** Edit 3's correction ACCEPTED, the jurist's `line_frame` shape WITHDRAWN (3rd substrate-refutes-composed-shape this session); the heavier rename correctly declined. **Q4** PROPOSAL/MINOR confirmed, the FIX reading **declined on the vacuity argument**. **Q5** Edit 2 kept (§V reads as a prose-framed universal alone; cross-section inference is what a successor cannot be assumed to perform). **Carry-forward for the REVIEWED entry, NOT spec text:** the primitives that would serve a future non-text kind already exist ratified (character-bearing image = content, hash-fixed, catalogued normalization, never silently dropped — REVIEWED-70 Q3; the Loeb sidecar's typed `{kind:'glyph', file:…}`) — nothing reserved, nothing promised, but a successor should find in the record that the architecture already pointed that way. **RULED 2026-07-25 — design-gate PASSED, with one REQUIRED correction** (`docs/kind-scoping-verification-JURIST-RULING-2026-07-25.md`). The jurist **adopted the package's Part-4 argument over his own framing**: the foreclosure is not that a non-text work *fails* the criterion but that the criterion is **VACUOUS** on it (empty re-extraction is trivially prose-word-identical to itself) — the false-positive shape, caught prospectively for the first time rather than after a finding. **Required correction:** Edit 1's *"that method is prose-word identity … (V-DSL · V-TEXT · V-SCAN)"* **overstates against V-SCAN**, whose ratified row says *no ground-truth text* and whose bar is *"a distinct, named, more-expensive criterion — not the deterministic bar relaxed"* — the scoping sentence must not flatten a distinction the table already draws. **Q1** placement at the evidence-tiers preamble CONFIRMED (that is where method is *defined*; tier-1 would scope the bar and leave the definition unscoped). **Q2** guard kept and **rebound to the property, not enrollment** (*"a text-bearing work … no work may weaken its applicable method"*) — as drafted it reached only existing kinds and would open the moment the door is first used. **Q3** Edit 3's correction ACCEPTED, the jurist's `line_frame` shape WITHDRAWN (3rd substrate-refutes-composed-shape this session); the heavier rename correctly declined. **Q4** PROPOSAL/MINOR confirmed, the FIX reading **declined on the vacuity argument**. **Q5** Edit 2 kept (§V reads as a prose-framed universal alone; cross-section inference is what a successor cannot be assumed to perform). **Carry-forward for the REVIEWED entry, NOT spec text:** the primitives that would serve a future non-text kind already exist ratified (character-bearing image = content, hash-fixed, catalogued normalization, never silently dropped — REVIEWED-70 Q3; the Loeb sidecar's typed `{kind:'glyph', file:…}`) — nothing reserved, nothing promised, but a successor should find in the record that the architecture already pointed that way.
**BUILT + LANDED 2026-07-25 (steward-authorized verbally; REVIEWED-75 placement 2026-07-27):** spec **v2.7.0** (v2.6.0 frozen `-v2.6.0.md`; **bounded-diff proven** — 1 deletion [the title line, reappearing as `(obsoleted)`] + 3 hunks [header stack · §V +6 · evidence-tiers +16], every other line v2.6.0 byte-preserved), both corrections applied verbatim to the ruling, + the sidecar-schema **generality note** (FIX) with its amendment-log row. Fleet 248/248 (doc-only change, baseline unmoved). CLAUDE.md brought current. **BUILT + LANDED 2026-07-25 (steward-authorized verbally; REVIEWED-75 placement 2026-07-27):** spec **v2.7.0** (v2.6.0 frozen `-v2.6.0.md`; **bounded-diff proven** — 1 deletion [the title line, reappearing as `(obsoleted)`] + 3 hunks [header stack · §V +6 · evidence-tiers +16], every other line v2.6.0 byte-preserved), both corrections applied verbatim to the ruling, + the sidecar-schema **generality note** (FIX) with its amendment-log row. Fleet 248/248 (doc-only change, baseline unmoved). CLAUDE.md brought current.
**Awaiting:** steward placement of REVIEWED-75 (draft ready, 2026-07-27). Related: REVIEWED-64 (`line_frame`/the declaration principle), REVIEWED-70 (§V character-as-image), REVIEWED-56 (sidecar additive-only lock discipline). **CLOSED 2026-07-27 — REVIEWED-75 PLACED** (`REVIEWED.md:710`). Landed as spec v2.7.0 (`e3b6aef`) + the sidecar-schema generality note; both required corrections applied against the live wording as the ruling directed. Nothing outstanding on this item. Related: REVIEWED-64 (`line_frame`/the declaration principle), REVIEWED-70 (§V character-as-image), REVIEWED-56 (sidecar additive-only lock discipline).