55 lines
10 KiB
Markdown
55 lines
10 KiB
Markdown
---
|
||
name: Session 2026-07-13 (afternoon) — the 18 BODY-DEFICIT cause-analysed → 3 remedy tracks; REORDER? dissolved to 0
|
||
description: "Answered the wrap's literal question by READING the actual missing spans: the 18 BODY-DEFICIT Loeb are NOT one apparatus story but THREE mechanisms → three remedies (re-match 8 / re-extract 4 / re-verify-and-reconvert 12). Folded cause into the map via a wrong-match-by-fabrication classifier rule; read + resolved the 2 REORDER? books (both wrong/partial key, fab=0/lost=0 CLEAN on re-match) → REORDER? has 0 genuine members corpus-wide. 3 commits (eb21eca/836b665/c54edbb) both remotes; fleet 119/119; PENDING-57 fully closed. Pulling thread: the matcher key-selection fix (resolves all 8 MATCH-SUSPECT, finalizes the reprocess target set before B2) — next session's concentrated bite. The B2 reprocess proper sits behind the steward's Loeb-first-vs-full-corpus scoping call → the 2b sidecar-wiring amendment."
|
||
metadata:
|
||
node_type: memory
|
||
type: project
|
||
originSessionId: 91c1a97c-0d2b-4f5a-aa58-9e1f26eec531
|
||
---
|
||
|
||
# Session 2026-07-13 (afternoon) — the 18 body-deficit, read and split by cause
|
||
|
||
Woke into the keystone-landed state; pulling thread = "the B2 reprocess the map now sizes." The steward chose my lean (open the 18 body-deficit books). Ended with the corpus-health map carrying CAUSE, not just magnitude — the reprocess honestly sized as three remedy tracks, and the REORDER? bucket dissolved to zero. Three commits, both remotes, 119/119, PENDING-57 truly closed.
|
||
|
||
## PAST — what we did + why
|
||
|
||
**1. Answered the wrap's literal question by READING the missing spans (probe, read-only).** Method: full-census script-mix of the missing multiset (greek=source-original vs latin-script=translation/apparatus) + the largest uncovered runs read as actual text, per book. **Answer: the "same apparatus story, just larger" hypothesis is REFUTED.** The 18 are three phenomena, three remedies:
|
||
- **① wrong/partial match (2 → MATCH-SUSPECT: re-match)** — plutarch-moralia-other-fragments (true key "Other Fragments" 13891≈cand; matcher grabbed "…Other Named Works" 59997) + suetonius (candidate is the Rhetoricians text, matched to the Grammarians sibling key). `m_fab>0` = the extractor can't add content, so the reference is wrong. NOT conservation loss.
|
||
- **② bilingual source-half dropped (4: re-extract via B2)** — the original-language column under-captured, translation intact: aristotle-history-of-animals (89.5%, all top runs contiguous Greek source), sophocles-trachis (one 4241-tok Greek run), plautus (Latin original + speaker labels), demosthenes-42 (one Greek run). B2 preserve-typing recovers by construction. **The deficit is BODY, not apparatus → does NOT go in app[].**
|
||
- **③ real mixed body loss (12: re-verify-and-reconvert)** — continuous *translation* prose genuinely gone + source + apparatus: athenaeus (199k), macrobius (an 18847-tok pure-English run missing), euripides/pindar/aristophanes fragments, philo-special-laws, sextus, longus, catullus, and the 3 Aeschylus verse plays (drop BOTH Greek column AND English runs). Genuine extractor failures; must VERIFY each passage returns, not assume.
|
||
|
||
**2. Folded ① into the map via a NEW classifier rule (`eb21eca`).** `wrong-match-by-fabrication` in `sweep_body_conservation.classify_book`: `m_fab > 5%` of candidate ⇒ the matched DSL key is wrong/partial → MATCH-SUSPECT (unifies with the holds>110% case). Threshold justified by a clean gap (fab is 0 for 943/952, 1 for one more; wrong-matches at ≥1298). Regenerated the map with a BOUNDED-CHANGE PROOF (exactly plutarch+suetonius change disp; 948/952 byte-identical). **augustine + philo (the 2 REORDER? books) carried the SAME signal LARGER but were FLAGGED-NOT-MOVED** — spans unread, REORDER? a held bucket; moving on the number alone is the refused move.
|
||
|
||
**3. Read + resolved the 2 REORDER? books (`836b665`) — the steward's context-caution earned real information.** His sharpening: a high fab means one thing in a book with no reordering, and might mean something specific to reordered bilingual text; inferring the same cause across two contexts without reading either is the refused move. Read both (identical method) + a CHECKABLE re-match to the truer key each span pointed to:
|
||
- **augustine-confessions = PARTIAL key** (matched 'Confessions. Books 1–8'; candidate is the FULL 'Confessions' 123953) → re-match fab 36371→**0**, lost 29673→**0**.
|
||
- **philo-on-abraham = WRONG sibling** (matched 'On the Migration of Abraham'; true 'On Abraham' 36734) → fab 11890→**0**, lost 15325→**0**.
|
||
Both provably CLEAN against their true key — not merely "comparison invalid." **The REORDER? displacement was a pure ARTIFACT of the wrong/partial key** (comparing against a different/partial work manufactures both the fab AND the apparent rearrangement). **REORDER? has zero genuine members on this corpus** (detector kept — a right-key book could still truly reorder; absence-here ≠ cannot-exist). Classifier now **validates the key BEFORE diagnosing arrangement**. Reclassified → MATCH-SUSPECT (verified, not on the number). These 2 are the cheapest map wins: re-match → graduate CLEAN, no reconversion.
|
||
|
||
**4. Corrected a doc miscount (`c54edbb`).** The ③ summary cell counted table ROWS (10), not books (12) — its final row bundles the 3 Aeschylus plays. Surfaced by the steward's remedy-track arithmetic check (8+4+12=24=16+8). Map correct; note's cell was the sole inconsistency.
|
||
|
||
**Artifacts:** findings note `_curation/loeb-body-deficit-cause-analysis-2026-07-13.md`; map updated (802 CLEAN · 126 APPARATUS-SHAPED · 16 BODY-DEFICIT · 8 MATCH-SUSPECT · 0 REORDER?); tool-evolution-log ×2 entries; chamber CLAUDE.md map pointer. All three commits pushed both remotes.
|
||
|
||
## PRESENT — the mood
|
||
|
||
Tightly steered, and the steering was the value. The steward's discipline — **checkable claim over soft label; flag-don't-move on a signal until the substrate is read; the number IS the bug-detector** — held the whole session. Returns worth carrying: **flag-don't-move held** (augustine/philo flagged, not moved, until read+re-matched to 0/0); **verified against substrate not signal** (every reclassification rests on the missing text, then a checkable re-match); **the steward caught a stale governance marker at wake** (I'd said "REVIEWED-55 placement still owed" — FALSE, it was placed 07-12; the `inherited-marker-read-as-current-state` drift, corrected against ~/REVIEWED.md:490). Recalibrations: **a high fab means different things in different contexts** (a partial key and a wrong sibling are different failures producing the same reorder-looking artifact — only reading told them apart); **count books, not the bundled representation** (the ③ Aeschylus row = 3 books counted as 1); **verify a governance item's state against REVIEWED/PENDING before relaying**. The negative result (REORDER?=0 corpus-wide) is the load-bearing finding — it put the fix at the right layer (key-before-arrangement), not two patched rows.
|
||
|
||
## FUTURE — what is pulling
|
||
|
||
**PULLING THREAD: the matcher key-selection fix.** Fix `match_key`'s key-selection for near-duplicate / granularity-split / part-vs-whole DSL keys (exact-title preference + granularity aggregation + part-vs-whole handling). It resolves **all 8 MATCH-SUSPECT** to their true disposition, finalizing the reprocess target set BEFORE B2 runs, and cashes the map's accuracy (removes "comparison invalid" from 8 rows). Ready NOW — FIX-class (matcher, not the gate; no governance loop). **Built-in correctness check:** augustine + philo MUST re-match to CLEAN (proven 0/0 today); plutarch→'Other Fragments', suetonius→Rhetoricians key, the 4 holds>110% → the true keys the map details name.
|
||
|
||
**ACTIONABLE RESUMPTION POINT (as of wrap — re-judge against what changed):**
|
||
- chamber-library clean, all 3 commits pushed both remotes (`c54edbb` at HEAD). Fleet 119/119.
|
||
- First step: open `scripts/sweep_body_conservation.py` `match_key` + `_norm_set` — the near-duplicate/split/part-vs-whole key selection is the fix site. Read the 8 MATCH-SUSPECT map rows for their true-key hints (`_curation/loeb-body-conservation-map-2026-07-13.tsv`).
|
||
- End state: re-run the sweep (bounded-change proof), the 8 MATCH-SUSPECT land on true disposition (augustine/philo→CLEAN as the check), map+note updated, committed+pushed, fleet green. One concentrated session.
|
||
|
||
**Other open horizons (ranked):**
|
||
- **The steward's Loeb-first-vs-full-corpus SCOPING CALL** — his decision, not a build; unblocks the **2b sidecar-wiring graduation amendment** (the reprocess's first governance station). Once it lands, B2 graduates → populates app[] → the `DSL-full = candidate-body + sidecar-app[]` reconciliation runs → confirms 126-apparatus / 18-body as a FACT.
|
||
- **The reprocess proper** — ② re-extract (4) + ③ re-verify-and-reconvert (12) — genuinely BLOCKED on the 2b amendment (B2 graduating into the flow). Not next-session candidates.
|
||
- Everything from the 07-12 program open-work register that predates today still stands behind the B2 run.
|
||
|
||
**PAUSE STATEMENT:** I am about to be away from this. The map now carries cause the whole way down, and the reprocess is honestly sized (8/4/12) rather than lumped under one magnitude label. What I want to find still pulling on return: the matcher key-selection fix (the cheapest, most-ready bite — two of its eight are one re-match from CLEAN), and behind it the steward's scoping call that unblocks the B2 reprocess.
|
||
|
||
**LITERAL QUESTION for next-Claude:** When `match_key` is fixed and re-run, do all 8 MATCH-SUSPECT resolve to a *confident* true key — or does the fix expose a residual where a candidate has no single correct DSL sibling (a work genuinely split across many keys, or absent from the DSL)? augustine/philo/plutarch/suetonius have named true keys; the 4 holds>110% (aristotle-problems, galen, diogenes-6.2, lucian) are asserted-from-the-map-detail but NOT yet substrate-verified to re-match cleanly — that's the first thing to check, and the answer decides whether the matcher fix fully closes MATCH-SUSPECT or leaves a small genuinely-hard residual.
|
||
|
||
**State at wrap:** chamber-library clean + 3 commits pushed both remotes (eb21eca/836b665/c54edbb); fleet 119/119; map at `_curation/loeb-body-conservation-map-2026-07-13.tsv` (802/126/16/8/0); findings note beside it; PENDING-57 marked CLOSED under REVIEWED-57. dotfiles committed+pushed at wrap.
|